bamboo shrimp died
3 posters
Page 1 of 1
bamboo shrimp died
awungfoo 2013-08-29, 17:10
My bamboo shrimp was active last night and feeding when I ladt saw him. I did do a 30% water change too and this morning, he was dead. Any insight?
awungfoo- Fry
- Join date : 2013-08-27
Re: bamboo shrimp died
Guest 2013-08-29, 18:43
Did you clean the filters too? If you did, you just killed all the Beneficial Bacteria in the filter with 30% water change. Did you put dechlorinizer (maybe wrong spelling)? I sometimes forget after a few hours. Oops
Guest- Guest
Re: bamboo shrimp died
pbmax 2013-08-29, 18:46
Not with that information.
How long have you had the shrimp?
Where did you get it?
How old is the tank? Is it planted? What else is in the tank?
What are your water water paramters? - PH, Ammonia, Nitrite, Nitrates, GH and KH if you have them, temperature?
How have you been feeding it? They're filter feeders so unless you're running a very mature tank, some powered foods or target feeding may be required.
Has it been picking at the substrate? This is a sign it's not getting enough food.
Do you have any high flow areas in your tank? Bamboo shrimp prefer high flow.
I know I've asked a lot of questions here, but these may help narrow down cause of death.
How long have you had the shrimp?
Where did you get it?
How old is the tank? Is it planted? What else is in the tank?
What are your water water paramters? - PH, Ammonia, Nitrite, Nitrates, GH and KH if you have them, temperature?
How have you been feeding it? They're filter feeders so unless you're running a very mature tank, some powered foods or target feeding may be required.
Has it been picking at the substrate? This is a sign it's not getting enough food.
Do you have any high flow areas in your tank? Bamboo shrimp prefer high flow.
I know I've asked a lot of questions here, but these may help narrow down cause of death.
pbmax- Lifetime Member
- Join date : 2011-12-23
Location : Olympia, WA
Re: bamboo shrimp died
pbmax 2013-08-29, 18:49
A 30% water change combined with a filter clean will NOT kill all the beneficial bacteria in the filter, unless you're cleaning it with a disinfectant or something.SiRWesDragon wrote:Did you clean the filters too? If you did, you just killed all the Beneficial Bacteria in the filter with 30% water change. Did you put dechlorinizer (maybe wrong spelling)? I sometimes forget after a few hours. Oops
I clean my filters whenever I like with tap water (un-chlorinated), often in conjunction with my bi-weekly 50% water changes. I've had no problems with this methodology.
pbmax- Lifetime Member
- Join date : 2011-12-23
Location : Olympia, WA
Re: bamboo shrimp died
Guest 2013-08-29, 19:00
Aquarium Co-Op wrote:Bacteria preservation(taking out decorations while cleaning, kills bacteria)
Amount of water changes/doing maintenance optimally. Don't change water, service your filters, remove decor etc all on the same day. A "Big cleaning job" is much worse than tackling one of those steps every 3 days for instance.
Guest- Guest
Re: bamboo shrimp died
pbmax 2013-08-29, 19:02
Every cleaning will eliminate some of your BB, but a blanket statement saying that all of someone's BB was killed because they did a 30% water change when they cleaned their filter is just not true.
pbmax- Lifetime Member
- Join date : 2011-12-23
Location : Olympia, WA
Re: bamboo shrimp died
pbmax 2013-08-29, 19:08
Besides which, tons of BB colonize the substrate and other surfaces of a mature tank as well. Unless the tank is really immature or over-stocked, properly cleaning a filter isn't a likely cause of tank disaster.
pbmax- Lifetime Member
- Join date : 2011-12-23
Location : Olympia, WA
Re: bamboo shrimp died
Guest 2013-08-29, 19:13
Im just repeating what other fishtank ppl like cory from co-op are saying.pbmax wrote:Every cleaning will eliminate some off your BB, but a blanket statement saying that all of someone's BB was killed because they did a 30% water change when they cleaned their filter is just not true.
Im not arguing. Thanks.
Last edited by SiRWesDragon on 2013-08-29, 23:03; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
Re: bamboo shrimp died
LuminousAphid 2013-08-29, 19:41
I tried one of these out for about a week, and then decided that it was too stressful wondering if she was getting enough food. I don't have any insight into why yours may have died, but they do seem to be very prone to stress, as mine would just hide for about 95% of the time I saw her even after being in the tank for a week. I kept worrying she wasn't getting enough food, and I don't want to have to worry about my creatures all the time, so I just took her back to aquarium co-op, Cory was more than happy to take her back.
They look cool when they are happy and fanning, but in my opinion, they are not really a beginners' shrimp. not saying you are a beginner, but I definitely am, and I wish I would have picked a couple amano instead
They look cool when they are happy and fanning, but in my opinion, they are not really a beginners' shrimp. not saying you are a beginner, but I definitely am, and I wish I would have picked a couple amano instead
LuminousAphid- Lifetime Member
- Join date : 2013-08-27
Age : 37
Location : Lynnwood -
Re: bamboo shrimp died
pbmax 2013-08-29, 19:48
I've had a single bamboo shrimp for years now. I've thought I'd killed it 3 or 4 times, but it always reappears. I've kept it in 3 different tanks, but it seems happiest in my 29g where I have pretty good flow. I leave a magnet cleaner on the glass and it perches underneath it, fanning in the spraybar flow. It's one of the few shrimp I haven't killed yet, strangely enough.
pbmax- Lifetime Member
- Join date : 2011-12-23
Location : Olympia, WA
Similar topics» Bamboo Shrimp
» Bamboo log/cave for plecos
» Discus died!
» Lucky bamboo and pea puffer fish tank experiment
» Most of our fish died within 1 day --Please help
» Bamboo log/cave for plecos
» Discus died!
» Lucky bamboo and pea puffer fish tank experiment
» Most of our fish died within 1 day --Please help
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum|
|
|